YouTube's copyright system isn't broken. The world's is.
Tom Scott · 13 位 HN 用户推荐 · 2020–2024
Tom Scott 用 40 多分钟讲清 YouTube 版权机制为何如此:问题出在法律本身
I think a more concrete term for unintuitive is outdated. The use cases for Copyright law were defined a century ago when society and technology was different. It is difficult for current citizens to understand copyright law because has nothing to do with their own day to day experiences and needs. Great video about Copyright by Tom Scott: [link]
— Hokusai, 2020Yes but an imitation is not necessary and usually a parody. There is a good Tom Scott's video about this distinction and other common misconceptions about copyright: [link] (42 interesting minutes)
— anonymfus, 2020> [link] algo's screwing up content creator A slightly different problem, but Tom Scott did an excellent video on the automation of the copyright system on YouTube: [link]
— peterkos, 2020For everyone asking "Why is YouTube's copyright system like it is? When is it going to change?", I suggest watching Tom Scott's video "YouTube's Copyright System Isn't Broken. The World's Is.": [link]
— CaliforniaKarl, 2020according to Tom Scott's very informative summary of all things [link] and copyright [1] there are seemingly reasonable alternatives to suddenly shutting down a whole channel - it seems like we're not getting the whole story as to why those were rejected or aren't being considered in this case? [1] [link]
— gfody, 2020Tom Scott has a great video on this topic. [link]
— harshitaneja, 2020A really great video (if you're willing to spend the better part of an hour watching it) about this is YouTube's Copyright System Isn't Broken. The World's Is.[1] by Tom Scott. [1] [link]
— 0xTJ, 2021I recommended checking out Tom Scott’s video on DMCA (0). It’s 40 minutes long and rather YouTube centric however it paints a very clear picture as to why these companies are engaging in a seemingly broken practice. It’s not because they want to, it’s because they are legally required to do so. (0) - [link]
— I_Byte, 2021I recommend the excellent video by Youtuber Tom Scott "YouTube's Copyright System Isn't Broken. The World's Is." [link]
— Laremere, 2021For anyone is interested, Tom Scott has a great video about YouTube copyright system: [link] .
— xucheng, 2021Tom Scott has a great video on Copyright: [link]
— monkeywork, 2022Tom Scott did a piece on it that’s worth watching: [link]
— happytiger, 2023