Debate Noam Chomsky & Michel Foucault - On human nature [Subtitled]
withDefiance · 4 位 HN 用户推荐 · 2015–2026
No one will deny that there are charlatans and poets posing as philosophers in the continental tradition. Tatterdemalion's post even prefaces with that. There are also straight up falsifiers and a endemic of p-value smudgers in the hard sciences. A good rebuttal to this Chomsky quote are the lovely debates he had with Foucault himself. [link]
— thwest, 2015Unfortunately, they're mostly speaking past each other, but it's still worth watching. [1] - [link]
— pmoriarty, 2019Foucault - and postmodernism in general - is all about narcissistic resentment. The link is here. Its very much worth watching. [link]
— nchmy, 2024some obvious follow-ups on practicality; even the most impassioned ASI boomer wouldn't argue that the exact ensembles used here could answer every question in the universe. But A) that's possible because some infinities are bigger than others, and B) the exact same caveat applies to humans, whose cognitive capabilities are thoroughly determined by accidents of biology, culture, and episteme. The l
— bbor, 2026