America Keeps Rejecting an ID Card It Already Has
CGP Grey · 12 位 HN 用户推荐 · 2017–2024
CGP Grey 讲美国社会安全号码的来龙去脉,以及它作为身份证号有多糟糕
And as to why the SSN is the way it is, it's a usage of convenience. Before the SSN there was no unique identifier for every citizen then suddenly to keep track of the new entitlement and assistance programs during the great depression one was created and companies started using it as they wanted because it was the most convenient uuid available. There's a good recent CGP Grey video about the hist
— rtkwe, 2017CGP has a good video on this: [link]
— sillysaurus3, 2017For everybody who isn't acquainted with how Social Security Cards work in the US and how they came to be I highly recommend watching "Social Security Cards Explained" by CGP Grey [link]
— sagitariusrex, 2017Passport numbers can't be used either because not all US citizens/residents have a passport and the numbers change when you renew them. Most parents get a SSN for their child at birth. Even people I know with dual citizenship overseas have them (all except for one, and you don't really need one unless you want to go to America to work .. and then you'll also need to pay an immigration/tax lawyer t
— djsumdog, 2017CGPGrey did an excellent video on this topic: [link]
— snuxoll, 2017CGP Gray did a really good video[1] about this recently. The short version is that it's the least terrible mechanism presently available for uniquely identifying and disambiguating American citizens. [1] [link]
— vec, 2017Here's a relevant pop science video by CGP Grey[0] that explains all the various problems with SSNs. My favorite part is the fact that until quite recently (2011) you could decrement or increment a given SSN by 1 and get another valid SSN, since they were sequential. [0]: [link]
— Qub3d, 2017There is great video about that by CGP Grey: [link]
— kozziollek, 2019CGP Grey did a great video a few years ago explaining how bad SSNs are. [link]
— playa1, 2019CGP Grey recently made a great video about this exact problem with social security numbers: [link]
— manigandham, 2019I'm late to the party, but CGP Grey has an excellent video detailing the flaws of how SSNs are utilized. [link]
— kalverra, 2023There's a really good video by CGP Grey that touched on this: [link]
— ajdude, 2024