Antonin Scalia - On American Exceptionalism
AmericanRhetoric.com · 8 位 HN 用户推荐 · 2019–2025
I wanted to add that, in the US, it isn't primarily the constitution that protects its freedoms, but rather the structure of their government and how it's been setup for gridlock among all the parties involved (not that that property has been preserved too well of late). Antonin Scalia explained it really well in one of his appearances in front of a Senate Judiciary Committee: [link]
— mvanga, 2019unding fathers' decisions reflect this, If we're to believe their commentary, they picked a republic with the motivation of liberty for all with emphasis on the elective structure, Constitutional Convention of Hamilton 1787 : "We are now forming a republican government...Real liberty is neither found in despotism or the extremes of democracy, but in moderate governments.” Scalia has a good talk a
— ethn, 2020Believe it or not, it's by design. 1. [link]
— splintercell, 2020What an excellent first video. I encourage everyone to watch it. Just 7 minutes: [link]
— sillysaurusx, 2020Yup. I recommend watching Justice Scalia talk about exactly that in this video: [link]
— bhupy, 2021Quite the opposite! Scalia had a great speech[0] where he argued that our Constitution is weak compared to other nations of history but had outlived those nations because of its slow nature to act. The point being, it doesn't matter how great your constitution is if your country is dead. [0] [link]
— jimbob45, 2023The design of the American system was always based on a distrust for power. The gridlock is the point. Not my favorite person but Scalia put it well: [link]
— letmevoteplease, 2023It depends on where you draw the line for acting in good faith. Justice Antonin Scalia's opening statement before a 2011 Senate Judiciary Committee hearing is worth watching. [link]
— emchammer, 2025