Music Theory and White Supremacy
Adam Neely · 9 位 HN 用户推荐 · 2020–2023
Adam Neely 论证西方「乐理」实为 18 世纪欧洲和声风格,反思其狭隘与偏见
If you examine the history of ideas of what is “real” or “authentic” or “objectively good” in music, who has been a proponent of those ideas through history, and why, you will find is that a lot of it is rooted in white supremacy. The idea is that a certain style of white European music is the only true music, and that other music is only valuable to the extent that it happens to fit within the th
— tobr, 2020Adam Neely has an entertaining video essay ranting about that in some detail: [link]
— guerrilla, 2021There's a very good video on the way too narrow view many people in the west have of music. [link]
— Kye, 2021Yup! Adam Neely has a great video[0] talking about how serious of a role any theoretical framework has on understanding the music itself -- and how in the US at least, we very often prescribe European standards of harmony on music. [0] [link]
— peterkos, 2021Adam Neely has a good video on how the term "music theory" here in the West is essentially just "the harmonic style of 18th century European musicians" [1]. It's worth a watch if you're interested in music. [1] [link]
— DavidVoid, 2021What criteria makes someone better? Is it some combination of technical skill at the keyboard, compositional skill at "the harmonic style of 18th century european music"[0] ? Is it the Fame that is achieved as a result of writing famous, lasting compositions? It is the music's complexity, or popularity? Does it have to be limited to so-called "classical" music, or music at all? [0] Adam Neely's e
— delgaudm, 2022And if anyone has time for a longer explanation, Adam Neely did a great video about "music theory" - sorry, I mean "the harmonic style of 18th century European musicians". It's worth watching. [link]
— viraptor, 2022Here’s a video you might find interesting of a microtonal guitar [link] Also a really good video on why “music theory” is often largely paired to western music [link] while there’s so many alternates out there
— dagmx, 2022I recommend Adam Neely on YouTube, he illustrates music theory concepts clearly, engagingly, and with an appropriate skepticism for received wisdom. Here's his discussion of some more political criticisms of music theory: [link]
— shirleyquirk, 2023