❝HN 片单

The Real Story Behind Wayland and X - Daniel Stone (linux.conf.au 2013)

Mladen Mijatov · 9 位 HN 用户推荐 · 2013–2025

Daniel Stone 讲清 X11 为何难以为继、Wayland 为何诞生

  1. Here's a good video explaining some of X's problems: [link]
    — runeks, 2013
  2. Daniel Stone actually did a talk involving much of the same subject matter called "The Real Story behind Wayland and X". I'd recommend that over this article (which was partially written by the same guy). He's actually a really charismatic speaker. [link]
    — jmhain, 2013
  3. If you have a wayland session on your computer, you don't want to hit ctrl-alt-8 to switch over to an X session running that single application, and then switch back and forth to wayland to use every other program. It would be nice if there was a X server that worked as a wayland client and could put the X-only application on your wayland desktop. That's Xwayland. * For a better explanation on di
    — forgottenpass, 2014
  4. Welcome to why Wayland is the future and X is deprecated. Daniel Stone's talk should be required viewing before anyone speaks on the X vs. Wayland issue: [link]
    — bitwize, 2015
  5. More direct and simpler (and therefore efficient) way to deal with drawing. X is bloated with tons of overhead and obsolete legacy stuff. Here is a good talk about it: (The Real Story Behind Wayland and X) [link]
    — shmerl, 2015
  6. For those who might want to understand why Wayland was created. Also tons of fun facts about X11. Really nice talk of Daniel Stone about X server from 2013: [link]
    — SXX, 2016
  7. I have my qualms with Red Hat too, but my point was that Wayland was created by Xorg developers because they tried and failed to make X11 competitive. Seriously, just go watch this XFree86/Xorg/Wayland developer's talk [1]. [1]: [link]
    — indolering, 2022
  8. For the full picture I think [link] is still a pretty good overview of why X11's design doesn't really apply well to modern usage. Particularly the second half of the "core X11" chapter.
    — kevincox, 2023
  9. I mean X11 was a pile of hacks, it became an unmaintainable pile of hacks. I think reduced scope was a good call, writing a display server is a hard problem. A lot projects started and failed to replace X11. If you feel this way I recommend watching this talk by Daniel Stone from linux.conf.au 2013, The Real Story Behind Wayland and X [link]
    — hacker_homie, 2025

← HN 片单