D/A and A/D | Digital Show and Tell (Monty Montgomery @ xiph.org)
FL Studio · 10 位 HN 用户推荐 · 2017–2026
xiph.org 的 Monty 用实验演示数字音频原理,破除“阶梯波形”等误解
You should take a look at [link] to get a better idea of how digital audio works.
— lgunsch, 2017Also, because cymbal sounds are pretty close to being noise, it's arguable whether it would matter or not. Although if you listen to a 128 kbps MP3 then you can often hear the top end frequency sounds (like cymbals) becoming 'mushy'. To the vast majority of people once you get to 192 kbps it's inaudible, and then above that most people with 'perfect ears' would struggle. And that's with a lossy fo
— louthy, 2018A great video which touches on this idea, but mostly in the context of audio: [link] (relevant part around 8 minutes)
— shawnz, 2019That’s a misconception. Monty from xiph.org explains it well. see [link]
— mc32, 2019The bit depth, OTOH, is your signal-noise ratio (noise floor) when sampling/quantizing said audio. It's unrelated to Nyquist-Shannon. More bits gives you less noise when reproducing it. For CD audio, 16 bits was chosen to give an acceptable SNR of 96 dB. Monty Montgomery (of xipf.org) has a nice YouTube video related to this: [link]
— colejohnson66, 2022Really good video on the topic from xiph.org [link]
— djmips, 2023Dithering is a feature. It’s used all the time in audio and image. And a little bit of noise is a good thing. Two of my favorite sources on the subject: [link]
— tambourine_man, 2023I mostly deal with this stuff in the realm of audio where the matter of analog vs digital rages regularly. The reason one hears "Nyquist says" so often from people defending digital audio is that the pro-analog people are imagining stair-stepped signals in which the information that is "lost" results in a noticeable degradation in sound quality. This (11-year-old) video is the gold standard for ad
— sramsay, 2024I am ashamed to admit this took me a long time to properly understand. For further reading I'd recommend: [link] [link]
— everfrustrated, 2026[link] or on YT if you can't play it [link]
— hackingonempty, 2026