❝HN 片单

Spec-ulation Keynote - Rich Hickey

ClojureTV · 22 位 HN 用户推荐 · 2016–2024

Rich Hickey 谈 API 变更与版本,批评 SemVer

  1. Rich Hickey just did a great talk about this sort of thing at Clojure Conj: [link]
    — Davertron, 2016
  2. This talk [1] by Rich Hickey seems more pertinent than ever. It's a contrarian stance on semver (which, almost as much as vc itself, is lauded as "the Right way" among developers). He definitely challenged my beliefs, it's likely to be worth your time too. [link]
    — sooheon, 2016
  3. guage, but it breaks binary compatibility between major versions because Scala's features don't map that well to the JVM's bytecode and the encoding of things like traits are fragile. Well, the community is kind of coping with it by having libraries support multiple major versions at the same time. Well, it's not much, but at least the tools have evolved to support this (e.g. SBT, IDEs, etc). Tha
    — bad_user, 2016
  4. There was a great talk recently by Rich Hickey[0] about how change itself is breakage. Breaking early and often is catastrophically worse than python 2.7 in my opinion. [0]: [link]
    — codemac, 2016
  5. Rich Hickey has a great talk on this: [link]
    — Anderkent, 2017
  6. Rich Hickey has a wonderful talk about it. "Spec-ulation" - [link]
    — pjmlp, 2017
  7. LTS would be a ton less necessary if people took backwards compat as seriously as some do. Rich Hickey has a great talk here [link]
    — bpicolo, 2017
  8. "Change isn't a thing. It's one of two things: Growth or Breakage." Growth means the code requires less, or provides more, or has bug fixes. Breakage is the opposite; the code requires more, provides less, or does something silly like reuse a name for something completely different. I recommend the whole talk, but the specific beef about SemVer starts here: [link]
    — slowmovintarget, 2018
  9. A very interesting talk by Rich Hikey (creator of Clojure) on the topic: [link]
    — _54qb, 2018
  10. Yes, Datomic is the killer app for Clojure [^1]. Have a look at Datascript[^2] and Mozilla's Mentat[^3], which is basically an embedded Datomic in Rust. Hickey's Spec-ulation keynote is probably his most controversial talk, but it finally swayed me toward dynamic typing for growing large systems: [link]
    — pgt, 2018
  11. ruuda pointed out an excellent talk/rant by Rick Hickey about the difficulties with versioning: [link]
    — jt2190, 2019
  12. To anyone who's interested in this topic, I strongly recommend this talk from Rich Hickey about "giving something to somebody that they can use and making a commitment": Spec-ulation ( [link] )
    — finalfantasia, 2019

← HN 片单