❝HN 片单

Why Your Vote Doesn't Count

CGP Grey · 15 位 HN 用户推荐 · 2012–2025

CGP Grey 动画讲解 FPTP 投票制为何导向两党制

  1. There is a nice series of YouTube videos on this topic on the C.G.P. Grey Explains channel. One specifically illustrates why the first-past-the-post system inevitably becomes a two-party system: [link]
    — acviana, 2012
  2. This is a symptom of first past the post voting. CGPGrey does a great series of simple videos demonstrating alternative voting methods that I found particularly enjoyable[0]. [0]: [link]
    — ixwt, 2015
  3. I highly recommend the following CGP Grey video for further detail about the problems of First Past the Post voting ( [link] ).
    — polymatter, 2015
  4. Ideologically, from a single voter's perspective, you're right. But practically, and looking at the entire population, it's not. The first past the post voting system we use will always result in two prominent parties, and the spoiler effect certainly exists. I've always found this video a good explanation of the problems of our voting system [link]
    — npizzolato, 2015
  5. It's an inevitable result of winner-take-all, first-past-the-post voting. This video explains the situation very well: [link]
    — byuu, 2016
  6. Here are my favorite videos on electoral reform: [link]
    — LoonyBalloony, 2017
  7. If someone is looking for a good explanation i must recommend this playlist by CGP Grey explaining different voting systems. [link]
    — lillecarl, 2020
  8. CGP Grey has excellent videos on this. Here's one that discusses the problems with the system the US uses now (in most states): [link]
    — DougWebb, 2020
  9. Check out this video, it helps explain why diversity of thought has little to do with the number of political parties that form in a system. [link]
    — viklove, 2021
  10. usually a side effect of first past the post voting systems. Since elections only allow voters to choose one candidate, a third party candidate end up splitting the vote and taking votes away from the candidate who is closest to their political stance. People see that and decide the rational choice is to vote for the candidate that they hate the least with the highest chance of driving, and third
    — mind-blight, 2021
  11. That's incorrect. The will of the people cannot necessarily be expressed when it has to be channeled through exactly two parties. The fact of there being two parties is dictated by the first past the post system. More detailed explanation: [link] (this is the famous CCP Grey video with the animals, for those who have already seen it).
    — javert, 2022
  12. That's pretty cool. There are a lot of voting systems that make a ton more sense than first past the post. One of my favorites on the topic is: [link]
    — reedjosh, 2022

← HN 片单